Is there any hope for the fifth season of ‘Sherlock’? Even if it is, a new season is unnecessary and would be a huge mistake- discover why!
‘Sherlock’, created by Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, was one of the classic detective stories that premiered on BBC in 2010. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes detective stories are the inspiration for the British crime television series. There have been thirteen episodes aired to date, with four three-part series airing from 2010 to 2017 and a special episode airing on January 1, 2016. ‘Sherlock’ has received critical acclaim for the calibre of its writing, acting, and directing. It has been nominated for numerous awards, including Emmys, BAFTAs, and a Golden Globe, and has won a number of them.
- Cumberbatch’s Holmes returning would be a big mistake
- It all depends on Cumberbatch and Freeman’s schedules
- ‘Sherlock’ Season 5 is not necessary because of its ending
Cumberbatch’s Holmes returning would be a big mistake
‘Sherlock’ made Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock Holmes and Martin Freeman as Doctor John Watson worldwide celebrities. Although there has been no official confirmation of a fifth season, viewers have been given numerous hints that the fifth season of ‘Sherlock’ could be in the works.
The first two seasons were well-received by critics and viewers, but the third and fourth seasons were less successful, and the fourth season got heavily criticised. Still, rumours about ‘Sherlock’ season 5 have been circulating for years, with Gatiss and Moffat occasionally giving fans hope, but ‘Sherlock’ season 5 would now be a mistake.
The final seasons of ‘Sherlock’ were not up to the standards. Season 3 of ‘Sherlock’ covered the Great Detective’s return after his supposed death in season 2’s finale ‘The Reichenbach Fall’. But the series failed to explain how Sherlock faked his death. With Sherlock back, the series shifted its focus to the introduction of Mary Morstan (Amanda Abbington) and the twist that she has a criminal past.
Although ‘Sherlock’ season 3 was a shambles, it paled in comparison to season 4, which saw the death of Mary and the introduction of Eurus Holmes (Sian Brooke). ‘Sherlock’ season 4 also continued season 3’s failed attempts to add more humour. It made Sherlock’s deduction skills completely unbelievable, undermining everything Sherlock built in its first two seasons. While it’s understandable that fans would like to see a new season after such failures, it’s too late for that and would only further harm the series.
It all depends on Cumberbatch and Freeman’s schedules
The first discussions about ‘Sherlock’ season 5 began in 2017, not long after season 4 aired, and the main issue from the start was Cumberbatch and Freeman’s schedules. Their careers took off thanks to Sherlock, and they are now both part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, among other projects. So it is understandable that finding a schedule that works for everyone has been difficult.
In 2017, Gatiss stated that ‘Sherlock’ season 5 could take “even longer” than two years, and Cumberbatch stated in 2021 that he would be open to a fifth season. But that he, Freeman, and “all the other key players” were too busy at the time.
Cumberbatch suggested that ‘Sherlock’ season 5 could instead be a film, and not long after, Freeman said he would be up for it but was not optimistic about it happening soon. Moffat insisted in April 2022 that he was still interested in resurrecting Sherlock. However, he also reminded the audience that, in the end, it all depends on Cumberbatch and Martin’s availability.
‘Sherlock’ Season 5 is not necessary because of its ending
Season 4 of ‘Sherlock’ was not a fan favourite among critics or viewers, but it did one thing right: it gave the show a true ending. The final episode of ‘Sherlock’ season 4 was by far the most messed-up and unbelievable episode in the entire series, with Eurus kidnapping Mycroft (Gatiss), Sherlock, and Watson and forcing them to play devious games to save their lives. But everything Eurus set up was incredibly difficult to believe.
After the mess got cleared up, Eurus was locked up in a mental institution again. But Sherlock paid her visits, and they played the violin together for their parents and Mycroft. John discovered a video message from Mary encouraging him to continue working with Sherlock. The detective and the doctor worked together in many, many more cases.
Even if season 4 harmed the show, ‘Sherlock’ season 5 isn’t necessary because the series was eventually given a proper ending with no loose ends.